How to file a diminished value claim

A plain, general guide: the steps, the documents to gather and what a demand letter should contain. It is general information, not legal advice, and it does not describe the rules of any particular state.

The steps

  1. Finish the repairs and keep every paper

    Keep the repair estimate, the final invoice, the parts list and any paperwork from the shop. They show what was damaged and what was fixed, which is the base of the whole claim.

  2. Find out who you are claiming against

    This guide is written for the common situation where another driver caused the accident and you deal with their insurer. Note the insurer's name, the claim number and the adjuster's contact details. Your situation and the rules that apply to it may differ, so check with your own insurer or an attorney if you are unsure.

  3. Work out what your car was worth before and what it is worth now

    Look at comparable cars (same year, make, model, trim and similar mileage) for sale in your area. Note the price of cars with a clean history and of cars with a repaired-accident history. A dealer or independent appraiser can give you a written opinion if you want something stronger than your own research.

  4. Put a number on the loss

    Our free diminished value calculator gives a rough, transparent estimate you can use as a starting point. It is not an appraisal, and insurers use their own methods. Open the calculator

  5. Write the demand letter

    A short, factual letter: who you are, what happened, what was repaired, how you calculated the loss, what you are asking for and by when. Outline below.

  6. Send it in a way you can prove

    Send by email with a read receipt and by a tracked postal service if you can. Keep copies of everything you send, with dates.

  7. Expect a counter-offer and keep records

    Insurers often respond with a lower figure or ask for more documents. Answer in writing, point back to your evidence, and keep a log of calls with dates and names. If the insurer refuses, your options may include asking for a written explanation, getting an independent appraisal, contacting your state insurance department, or speaking to an attorney. Time limits for claims exist and differ, so do not wait.

Documents to gather

  • Repair estimate and final repair invoice
  • Photos of the damage and of the finished repair
  • Police report or accident report, if there is one
  • Insurer name, claim number and adjuster contact
  • Vehicle details: year, make, model, trim, VIN, mileage at the time of the accident
  • Proof of the car's value before the accident: comparable listings or a valuation printout
  • A vehicle history report showing the accident record, if available
  • Your estimate of the loss and how you calculated it

Sample letter outline

  1. Your name, address, phone and email, and the date
  2. Insurer name and address, claim number, date and place of the accident
  3. A one-paragraph summary of what happened and that the other driver caused it
  4. What was damaged and repaired, with the repair total
  5. The car's market value before the accident and your estimate of the loss, with the method explained
  6. The amount you are asking for and a reasonable date to respond by
  7. A list of the documents you are attaching

Keep the tone calm and factual, and avoid threats. State only facts you can document.

Prefer it done for you?

The claim kit is this guide, filled in for your car: an estimate with its method explained, a demand letter and an evidence checklist. You send it yourself; we do not contact the insurer or promise any payout.

Order the claim kit

$79 one-time, no subscription. Delivered by email. Part of the work is done by hand, so allow at least 1 day; we will confirm a delivery date once we have your details.

By ordering you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy. Refund if we cannot deliver your kit.

We are not a law firm or adjuster; you send the claim yourself and no result is guaranteed. Not available for Florida. If you live in the EU, EEA, UK or Switzerland: by paying you ask us to start work immediately and accept that you lose your 14-day withdrawal right once the kit has been fully delivered (see Terms).

General information only, not legal advice. Rules and time limits differ by state and by situation; for advice on yours, ask a licensed attorney or your state insurance department.